Full search page →

DLCV 04 · A sharp guess can be less faithful

AdvancedDLCV 09 · Deep Image Restoration: Low-Level VisionInteractive plot

Description

A blurry observation fits two sharp clean signals. The blurry average has the lowest expected squared error; a sharp guess looks better but is usually farther from the truth.

Try this: Start from the sharp copy of A (commitment 1): its risk is higher than the blurry mean's. Slide the commitment to 0 and watch the risk fall to the minimum. Then raise the probability of A to 0.9: does the sharp copy of A catch up, and can it ever win?

Predict first

Set P(A) = 0.9. The sharp copy of A is now very likely correct. Does the blurry mean still have the lower expected squared error?

Explanation

Answer the prediction first, or open the explanation when you are ready.

Show the explanation

The mean has risk p(1−p) = 0.09 and the sharp copy of A has risk 1−p = 0.10. The gap shrinks as p approaches 1 but never closes, because the mean is the exact minimizer of expected squared error.

Lab · DLCV 04 · A sharp guess can be less faithful

Predict first

Set P(A) = 0.9. The sharp copy of A is now very likely correct. Does the blurry mean still have the lower expected squared error?

Expected reconstruction MSE
0.5
Conditional-mean minimum MSE
0.25
Sharpness (adjacent total variation)
3

Averaging incompatible possibilities minimizes expected squared error, but can remove structures present in every valid clean outcome. Choosing one restores structure while risking the wrong structure.

Try this: Start from the sharp copy of A (commitment 1): its risk is higher than the blurry mean's. Slide the commitment to 0 and watch the risk fall to the minimum. Then raise the probability of A to 0.9: does the sharp copy of A catch up, and can it ever win?

Two fixed 8-sample patterns, A = 00110011 and B = 11001100, are the only clean signals that could have produced the same blurry observation. P(A|y) = p is supplied, not learned. The blurry mean is p·A + (1−p)·B. Your reconstruction blends the mean toward A: (1−m)·mean + m·A, so m = 1 is exactly A (a sharp sample) and m = 0 is the mean. Risk = the expected mean squared error, p·MSE(A, output) + (1−p)·MSE(B, output), averaged over which pattern is the truth. Sharpness is the total variation (sum of absolute differences between neighbouring samples), not a perceptual quality score.

Method sources

Open in the Playground →